Thanksgiving, 2003

   The following reviews were presented in our 2003 Thanksgiving feature.

Reviews

Biscuit Is Thankful
Alyssa Satin Capucilli
Illustrated by Pat Schories
   Biscuit, a small yellow puppy, reminds us that everyday there are things for which we should be thankful. As his owner, a little girl, feeds him and takes him for a walk, we learn that Biscuit is thankful for his bed and biscuits, a morning walk and crunchy leaves, and good friends. Dogs and children romp in a pile of colorful leaves. A tree with bare branches also signifies the fall season, making this appropriate to use at Thanksgiving with small children. Humorous scenes, such as when Biscuit becomes entwined in his leash as he tries to catch a bunny, and the presence of several playful kittens make this an eye catching book for toddlers and preschoolers. Those who have enjoyed the other Biscuit board books will enjoy this too. 2003, HarperCollins, Ages 2 to 5, $4.99. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 0-694-01519-9

A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving
Charles M. Schulz
   Based on the home video and television special, this "Peanuts" books, A Charlie Brown Thanksgiving, reads as a transcript of the familiar holiday special. Children who loved the show will enjoy reminiscing Snoopy's silly antics as a dog who challenges himself to an impromptu game of ping pong and then later dons a chef hat as he whips up some popcorn and then deals the Thanksgiving dinner of pretzels, popcorn and jellybeans like a deck of cards. The book would be a good excuse to get a reluctant reader reading since it is adapted from TV. The adaptation doesn't make for a well-flowing story, but it is simple and amusing and the large color illustrations of Charlie Brown and the gang are a treat. As always, the Charlie Brown message is light and sweet-a reminder that Thanksgiving is more about the people you are with than where your are or what you eat. 2002, Little Simon/Simon & Schuster Children's, Ages 4 up, $5.99. Reviewer: Sarah Seage
ISBN: 0-689-85027-1

A Comfy, Cozy Thanksgiving
Kiki Thorpe
Illustrated by Tom Brannon
   Part of the "Bear in the Big Blue House" series, A Comfy, Cozy Thanksgiving is a cautionary tale animated by creatures from the Henson workshop. Bear, Ofo, Pip and Pop, and Tutter are preparing Thanksgiving dinner for the Big Blue House. Treelo (clearly the baby of the family because he lacks the ability to use articles in a sentence) desperately wants to be involved. He goes around asking each friend, "Treelo help?" But everyone is either too busy or the task is too difficult for the little lemur. Treelo quickly gets the message that he is simply in the way (is this story written for children or for the adults?). He decides the best thing to do is go elsewhere for Thanksgiving but as he discovers, the best place for Thanksgiving ends up being where you are most wanted-even if everyone momentarily forgets you. The illustrations are computer-generated images that incorporate photographs of the muppet characters with watercolor clothes, accessories, and background. Perhaps a good book for children who are fans of the Big Blue House TV show on the Disney channel. 2002, Simon Spotlight/Simon & Schuster, Ages 4 to 8, $5.99. Reviewer: Sarah Seage
ISBN: 0-689-85012-3

The Complete Book of the Seasons
Sally Tagholm
   Not only weather is treated in this comprehensive middle grades book, although it occupies the lion's share of the pages. You'll also find sections on seasonal holidays, animals and their weather-related habits, plants and how they change as temperatures change, things to do in appropriate seasons, and sports for days cold and warm. This beautifully designed book boasts several illustrators, yet their work overlaps seamlessly to produce an integrated whole. Summer presents an opportunity to discuss the Verona opera festival in an ancient Roman amphitheater; Fall provides a setting to the Chinese moon festival of Thanksgiving; Winter unfolds to a spread on ice skating; and Spring features pages about the constellations. This reviewer, however, did not care for the inclusion of St. Patrick's Day, a Catholic festival, as a day "celebrated by people all around the world-whether or not they are Irish." A more honest treatment of religious holidays, such as that given to the summer festival of Esala Perahera, which honors a tooth believed to have belonged to the Buddha and is not presented as secular, would have been preferred. Christmas and Chanukah, Easter and Passover are mercifully left out except in the Seasonal Events listing at the end. This is a very worthwhile and refreshing book. 2002, Kingfisher, Ages 8 to 12, $18.95. Reviewer: Judy Chernak
ISBN: 0-7534-5457-2

Countdown to Thanksgiving
Jodi Huelin
Illustrated by Keiko Montoyama
   Not all counting books count up; this one starts with ten. A celebration of the traditions of Thanksgiving, the festivities begin with the arrival of 10 family members. The daughter has arranged 9 flowers for the centerpiece of the dinner table. Eight steps lead to the basement where the kids play while the adults make dinner. Grandma takes a 5-minute snooze during the preparation for the feast. The traditional ingredients of turkey, pie and a variety of vegetables all make an appearance. The artwork is pleasant and colorful. There are some surprising messages that could be more kid and senior friendly. Children are not involved in the preparation of the food and seem to be relegated to peripheral status. It would be nice to see family groups that represent a wider ethnic diversity. The important message is family and sharing in a holiday all Americans can call their own. 2002, PriceStern Sloan, Ages 3 to 6, $3.99. Reviewer: Kristin Harris
ISBN: 0-8431-4880-2

Dora's Thanksgiving
Sarah Wilson
Illustrated by Robert Roper
   Dora the Explorer fans will be happy to share her celebration of Thanksgiving. What is she most thankful for? Her Mami and Papi. Told in first person, Dora continues to ask questions about people and things that make her thankful and then she offers clues. Her answers are in Spanish and the pictures offer further explanation. Dora also asks the readers to think about being thankful. "Do you have a friend you are thankful for? Who is your friend?" Dora is ever alert for Swiper, the fox, and just manages to save the pies she is bringing to Thanksgiving dinner. Based on the television series, "Dora the Explorer", the book is one of several in the series. Many of the stories are also available in Spanish. Bright colors, wide-eyed familiar characters, and adventure are appealing to young children. Simon Spotlight/Nick Jr./Simon & Schuster, Ages 2 to 5, $3.99. Reviewer: Laura Hummel
ISBN: 0-689-85842-6

The First Thanksgiving of Low Leaf Worm
Richard Scarry
   Low Leaf Worm belongs to the Wampanoag tribe in New England. When Englishmen from the Mayflower arrive he studies these wautaconuoag or coat-men. He observes them building houses and trying to survive in this new land. Many die during the winter. Tisquantum (Squanto) who speaks English arrives to teach the newcomers how to plant and fish. In return, the Englishmen hold a feast and share their bounty with their neighbors. Told through the eyes of a Native American, the story of Thanksgiving gives young readers another perspective of the classic American holiday. Detailed pen and color drawings invite children to study the simple illustrations while looking for Low Leaf. Additional historical information is included under lift flaps and an illustrated timeline is at the back of the book. Educators and Richard Scary fans should enjoy this historic celebration. Little Simon/Simon & Schuster, 2003, Ages 4 to 7, $6.99. Reviewer: Laura Hummel
ISBN: 0-689-84846-3

Five Little Turkeys
William Boniface
Illustrated by Lynn Adams
   Countdown to Thanksgiving with five tiny molded turkey pieces that peek through cut holes in the book cover. "Five little turkeys bolted out the barnyard door. One stopped off to gather hay, leaving just..." Turn the page and only four turkeys remain. As each page is turned, another turkey disappears until one, who refuses to be afraid, remains...and he pops-up to lead the Thanksgiving Day parade. Sturdy construction, tangible turkeys, and diminutive size will surely appeal to young readers. Colorful illustrations and rhyming text make this a clever tool for learning to count backwards from five. Price Stern Sloan 2003, Ages 2 to 5, $5.99. Reviewer: Laura Hummel
ISBN: 0-8431-0464-3

The Memory Cupboard: A Thanksgiving Story
Charlotte Herman
Paintings by Ben F. Stahl
   How wonderful to see a contemporary book that has a family traveling by train to visit grandma for Thanksgiving. Once there, the family is welcomed by all of their distant relatives. The snow is falling on this Thanksgiving holiday so we can only assume that the setting is in the Midwest or even further west. Grandma keeps track of her young granddaughter's activities and we see the letters and drawing posted in the kitchen. The family has a great time with its traditions and remembrances. One of the items of great interest is the gravy boat with its blue flowers. Katie hears the story of how her mother and uncle broke their piggy banks to buy the gravy boat as a Mother's Day present. Imagine how Katie feels when that gravy boat slips from her fingers and shatters into pieces. Grandma however, shares a secret and readers and Katie learn about the Memory Cupboard and what is really important in a family. The pictures are realistic and contemporary and the story is a warm intergenerational one that should resonate with most kids. 2003, Albert Whitman, Ages 5 to 8, $15.95. Reviewer: Marilyn Courtot
ISBN: 0-8075-5055-8

My Book of Thanks
B. G. Hennessy
Illustrated by Hiroe Nakata
   "Dear God...Thank you for me!" begins this prayer for young children. From its child-centered beginning, it broadens to thank God for family, friends, and "people who teach me about your world." There are thanks for playtime, food to eat, for the earth, and for "EVERYTHING." After the initial thanks, each has another sentence that gives direction on how to show thanks and kindness. The watercolor illustrations show happy, multicultural children at play and families together. They offer a variety of settings from around a table, to the playground, and on to a busy street. Little details will bring a smile to the reader's face. A quiet, thoughtful book, this is perfect for bedtime sharing between parents and their children, or for adults to use with their students in religious education classes. 2002, Candlewick Press, Ages 4 to 8, $12.00. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 0-7636-1523-4

P is for Pilgrim: A Thanksgiving Alphabet
Carol Crane
Illustrated by Helle Urban
   This book is aimed at an audience older than the usual consumers of alphabet books. Each letter is accompanied by a four-line verse which uses many key words beginning with the letter, as well as a sidebar of text providing some historical context. For example, "D" has "Drums, dances, and games,/deer moccasins from animal skin./Dyes for clothing and blankets,/Pilgrims thank their native friends again"--while the sidebar details information about games played during the original Thanksgiving feast and uses for cranberries. Full color, detailed illustrations depict people and scenes related to the topics presented. Not all of the topics presented relate to the original Thanksgiving feast; "B" is for "Bill of Rights," and "E" reviews the history of educator and editor Sarah Josepha Hale who lobbied for the institution of Thanksgiving as a national holiday. Some of the text is a bit heavy-handed ("R" is for "all races in our republic") but lots of new and interesting information is provided in a format that invites browsing. The book is likely to be most useful as a classroom supplement for a Thanksgiving unit. 2003, Sleeping Bear Press/Gale Group, Ages 6 to 10, $14.95. Reviewer: Dr. Judy Rowen
ISBN: 1-58536-134-8

The Perfect Thanksgiving
Eileen Spinelli
Illustrated by JoAnn Adinolfi
   Our young narrator describes the Thanksgiving festivities of two families, her own and that of Abigail Archer. The lilting verse tells us that Abigail's family is "perfect in every way." They hold hands around their candle-lit table, awaiting their plump, golden turkey, which will be eaten in dainty bites. Afterwards they take walks, or read, while the other family deals with burnt turkey, uncouth eating, and wild behavior afterwards. Even the sleeping arrangements contrast, with guests at the Archers' having private rooms as opposed to sleeping bags on the floor. But the families are alike, we are assured, in "the nicest way by far-/ alike in just how loving/ our different families are." Adolfi's kid's-eye visuals add zip to the events of the holiday. Pseudo-child-like colored pencil drawings with gouache paint topped by collage bits on rather frantic double-page layouts enhance the comparisons between the families. There is plenty to examine and enjoy, along with the warmth of the message. 2003, Henry Holt and Company, Ages 4 to 8, $15.95. Reviewers: Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz

The Perfect Thanksgiving
Eileen Spinelli
Illustrations by JoAnn Adinolfi
   Celebrating the diversity of family celebrations, this book features two very different families. The young narrator first describes Abigail Archer's traditional Thanksgiving. The turkey at Abigail's is beautiful and golden. They have lace napkins and lit candles on their exquisitely decorated table. In contrast, the narrator's family has a turkey, burnt as toast, which sets off the fire alarm. Alternate pages continue to contrast the two families. Abigail's family eats daintily and quietly. The narrator's family chews, chomps, slurps, and sings. After-dinner activities and experiences with overnight guests continue the contrasting traditions. Large, cartoon-like pictures in bold colors illustrate the events and add humor to the text. A turkey traced around a hand accompanies the speaker's family while a large colorful turkey attends Abigail's activities. The concluding page honors both families as being loving and perfect. A delightful addition to the Thanksgiving books collection. 2003, Henry Holt, Ages 4 to 8, $15.95. Reviewer: Phyllis Kennemer
ISBN: 0-8050-6531-8

Round the Turkey: A Grateful Thanksgiving
Leslie Kimmelman
Illustrated by Nancy Cole
   An American family gathers for Thanksgiving, and each member takes a turn expressing their gratitude for the year's blessings. "It's Thanksgiving, it's November. Take a minute to remember all the blessings of the year, round the table, starting here." Written in rhyming verse, each family member reflects on the past year. Aunt Terry is grateful for being able to fly over seas and adopt her daughter, Kaitlyn. Kaitlyn is thankful for her dog Ike. Sophie is grateful for her baby brother, Uncle Hershey is grateful for the food they are about to eat. A separate verse on each page accompanied by lively color illustrations makes this a fun holiday read aloud. Also another way to introduce poetry to the youngest readers. 2002, Albert Whitman & Company, Ages 4 to 8, $15.95. Reviewer: Cheryl Peterson
ISBN: 0-8075-7131-8

Snuffy's Thanksgiving
Adapted by Kelly Chipponeri
   Intended to introduce young children to the concept of Thanksgiving, little airplane Snuffy wonders what he has to be thankful for. He and Jay Jay have flown into town to get vegetables for the big meal. When they arrive back at the airport Old Oscar informs them that there is a big snowstorm approaching the North Pole. Big Jake has just made a delivery of Thanksgiving dinner to the scientists at the North Pole, and the storm may keep him from getting back in time for their own Thanksgiving feast. Snuffy is worried; Thanksgiving just won't be the same without Big Jake. Old Oscar was able to give Big Jake advice that got him out of the storm, but he hit fog as he approached the airport at home. The planes all work together and get Big Jake down. Snuffy is thankful they are all together. Airplanes with faces are unique characters and it is quite an unusual sight to see them pulled up around a table of food. These characters are based on the PBS series Jay Jay The Jet Plane. 2002, PriceStern Sloan, Ages 3 to 6, $3.49. Reviewer: Kristin Harris
ISBN: 0-8431-4549-8

Sometimes It's Turkey, Sometimes It's Feathers
Lorna Balian and Lecia Balian
   This story written thirty years ago has been give a fresh new look by the authors daughter who has added full color to her mother's illustrations. It is not an unfamiliar tale. A perky little old lady, Mrs. Gumm, finds a turkey egg and takes loving care of it. Once it hatches, the turkey eats everything in site, but the little lady doesn't mind. She just keeps commenting to her cat "What a fine Thanksgiving dinner we will have." As the seasons pass and the turkey grows plumper, the tension builds. The preparations for the Thanksgiving dinner have been made, the hatchet has been sharpened, but Mrs. Gumm can't dispatch her turkey. Instead she invites it to join her and cat for a Thanksgiving dinner. After all there is always next year. Other stories about the inability to dispatch the bird for dinner include Gracias, the Thanksgiving Turkey by Joy Cowley with illustrations by Joe Cepeda (Scholastic), Holiday House's A Thanksgiving Turkey by Julian Scheer with illustrations by Ronald Himler, and A Turkey for Thanksgiving by Eve Bunting with illustrations by Diane de Groat (Clarion). There are also several amusing books with turkey's outwitting those who plan to have them for dinner. Younger kids may be disturbed, older readers will chuckle at the humor. 2004 (orig. 1973), Star Bright Books, Ages 4 to 8, $12.95. Reviewer: Marilyn Courtot
ISBN: 1-932065-33-4

Spot's Thanksgiving
Eric Hill
   Little Spot the dog is getting ready for Thanksgiving. He has decided to make a pumpkin pie. His dad donates his best pumpkin and mom rolls out the dough. The grandparents arrive with a Pilgrim hat and Spot wears it to serve his pie. They all agreed that it was a great dinner and wish everyone a Happy Thanksgiving! Young children will surely enjoy this addition to the "Fun with Spot" books. Simple text, bright colors, and happy dog expressions will be inviting to young readers. Sturdy board binding and the compact size should be just right for little hands. G.P. Putnam's Sons, 2003, Ages 2 to 5, $5.99. Reviewer: Laura Hummel
ISBN: 0-399-24186-8

Stories That Stick: Quick & Easy Storyboard Tales
Valerie Marsh
Illustrations by Patrick Luzadder
   After an introduction that discusses how to use this book and the range of skills that are built through storytelling, Marsh divides the content into three areas: Songs and Poems, Aesop's Fables, and Folktales. Among the nine songs and rhymes are Old McDonald had a Farm, In a Dark, Dark House, Five Little Monkeys and The Bear Went Over the Mountain. One familiar fingerplay has been adapted for Halloween, Thanksgiving, winter, St. Patrick's Day, and Easter. Included among the fables are the very familiar, such as The Tortoise and the Hare, as well as less familiar, such as Belling the Cat. Simple tales such as the Three Billy Goats Gruff to the more sophisticated Magic Fish are found in the third section. Valerie Marsh's retellings are simple and easy to learn. These are traditional pieces that will not only stick to the storyboard, but will stick in the listener's mind for years to come. Discussion questions conclude each story/song. The pictures required for the storyboard are listed prior to the story. Patterns for the characters and settings can be found in the back of the book. The cartoon style works for the majority of the characters, although this reviewer has difficulty with the monkeys, which seem to be more grotesque than comical. Beginning storytellers, librarians and teachers will find a treasure trove here to use with children ages 3 to 8. As Marsh states in her final storytelling rule: "Enjoy!" 2002, UpstartBooks, Ages 3 to Adult, $15.95. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 1-57950-068-4

Thank You, Sarah: The Woman Who Saved Thanksgiving
Laurie Halse Anderson
Illustrated by Matt Faulkner
   Thanksgiving was not always a national holiday. It took the tenacity of a superhero to make it so. According to the author of this lively account that person was Sarah Hale. "She was bold, brave, stubborn, and smart. And Sarah Hale had a secret weapon.... a pen." Yes, this is the same Sarah Hale who gave us the poem, "Mary Had a Little Lamb." Anderson employs a folksy style, complete with old-fashioned expressions, such as "When folks started to ignore Thanksgiving, well, that just curdled her gravy." She speaks directly to the reader, providing information about Hale's life, the times in which she lived, and her determination to preserve Thanksgiving Day. This lively telling is accompanied by energetic mixed-media illustrations full of humor as well as details of mid-nineteenth century life. While this is a great book for Thanksgiving units, or for parents and children to share in November, it would be a shame for it to sit on a shelf the rest of the year. There are many ways this book can be used in a classroom or for study. Teachers and students can begin by discussing how this is an apt title for the book. It would make a good introduction for social studies units on the presidents, events, and social causes of mid-nineteenth century America (Civil War; Slavery, Women's Rights) as well as the importance today of citizen involvement in government. This finely crafted book can be used in language arts units to discuss literary devices, such as point of view, imagery, atmosphere, theme, and others. And of course, since Hale's campaign was primarily one of letter writing, this emphasizes the importance of being able to state one's thoughts through clear and concise writing. A "Feast of Facts" can be found in the back of the book and provides more detailed information for older children and adults. A list of selected sources rounds out the research information. 2002, Simon & Schuster, Ages 5 to 10, $16.95. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 0-689-84787-4

Thank You, Thanksgiving
David Milgrim
   With his stylized drawings and a very simple repetitive text, Milgrim takes us on an outing one Thanksgiving Day. The family has eaten dinner and on what is apparently a day after a big snowfall; a young gal sets out for the store. It can't be too cold because she isn't wearing any mittens or gloves. She is thankful for all of the ordinary things in life-warm boots, the sweet sound of birds, clouds in the sky and the animals that she encounters along the way. At the store she purchases the whipping cream that was obviously her mission and a few other items. She feeds the carrots to the rabbits and the bread to the duck. After her sledding adventure down a hill, I would have expected that the cream would be nearly whipped. However, once safely home she helps get it whipped up the traditional way so it can be served on the pies. The final scene even shows the animals enjoying a bit of the holiday treat. 2003, Clarion/Houghton Mifflin, Ages 3 to 6, $9.95. Reviewer: Marilyn Courtot
ISBN: 0-618-27466-9

Thanksgiving
Cynthia Klingel and Robert B. Noyed
   Simple sentences and controlled vocabulary introduce readers to the origins of this American holiday. Two sentences in large type are on each page. An index, brief bibliography of children's books and a website on Thanksgiving can be found at the back of the book. Part of the "Wonder Books" series (nonfiction level two), readers will learn when, how and why it is celebrated. Photos of families together, some of the food, and several prints of the ways various artists depicted the first Thanksgiving and the events that led up to it give visual clues to the readers. Just enough information is provided for beginning readers to successfully complete a book and learn some facts as well. 2003, The Child's World, Ages 5 to 8, $21.36. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 1-56766-956-5

Thanksgiving
Natalie M. Rosinsky
   In a question and answer format, readers will learn how the first Thanksgiving came about, how it became a national holiday, what are the symbols of the holiday, how it is observed in the United States, and how other nations celebrate their own thanksgiving. A glossary, bibliography, websites, information on Plimoth Plantation, and an index are included. One page is devoted to each question, and two or three paragraphs provide the answer. Words in bold type are defined in the glossary. A clear, color photograph accompanies each question. Some artist renditions depicting the Pilgrims and the Wampanoag are used. Readers will gain understanding through the carefully formed sentences. Part of the "Let's See Library" series, this will fill a need for a book just beyond the beginning-to-read level. Additionally, it can be used with older students who have difficulty reading. 2002, Compass Point Books, Ages 6 to 8, $18.60. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 0-7565-0391-4

Thanksgiving at the Tappletons'
Eileen Spinelli
Illustrated by Megan Lloyd
   Thanksgiving is always a big day at the Tappletons' when the family, plus grandmother and grandfather, uncle and aunt, gather for the traditional feast. On this particular day, however, everything seems to go wrong. The turkey slips away from Mrs. Tappleton at the door and sinks into the pond. Mr. Tappleton brings only empty boxes from the bakery, since all the pies are sold. Young Kenny realizes he can't make the salad because he has fed all the greens to the rabbits. And young Jenny loses control of the mixer as the mashed potatoes fly everywhere. Each has to admit the error to the hungry folks at the table. But good nature wins out as they make the best of what's available to eat in cupboards and refrigerator, for "most of all...they had each other." Lloyd's watercolor drawings create a fine family of anthropomorphic wolves dressed for the holiday. The dining room is set with a mixed collection of chairs in which sit the expectant folk. The details of the inside and outside and the several action sequences are particularly successful in creating a lively, humorous visual tale with a heart-warming moral. 2003 (orig. 1982), HarperCollins Publishers, Ages 4 to 8, $14.99. Reviewers: Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz
ISBN: 0-06-008670-X

Thanksgiving at the Tappletons'
Eileen Spinelli
Illustrations by Megan Lloyd
   With joyous enthusiasm the Tappletons begin their preparations for their Thanksgiving feast. Alas, the big uncooked turkey slides away and into a pond when Mrs. Tappleton reaches for the milkman's eggnog. Unaware of this disaster, Mr. Tappleton leaves to pick up the pies. He waits in a nearby coffee shop for the line to go down at the bakery. When it does, the pies are gone. In the meantime, Kenny cannot complete his task of preparing the salad because he took the vegetables to school to feed the rabbits. Jenny gets so engrossed in a telephone chat that she lets the mashed potatoes fly all over the room. When Uncle Fritz and the grandparents arrive, everyone sits down to the dining room table. They gradually discover that there is no Thanksgiving dinner -- no turkey, no fixings, nothing. Unabashed, Grandmother offers the before meal prayer giving thanks for the family and their togetherness. Then everyone pitches in to fix a meal with what's on hand. They feast on liverwurst cheese sandwiches, pickles, and applesauce. Lively illustrations feature a family of wolves with wonderfully human characteristics. A good story to share with children when discussing the true meaning of Thanksgiving. 2003, HarperCollins, Ages 5 to 9, $14.99. Reviewer: Phyllis Kennemer
ISBN: 0-06-008670-X

Thanksgiving Day
Anne Rockwell
Illustrated by Lizzy Rockwell
   Mrs. Madoff's class put on a play about the Wampanoag people and the Pilgrims who come to live with them in America. Everyone in the class is thankful for the special things that made the first Thanksgiving feast possible. The simple text and lovely illustrations make this an excellent book to explain our first Thanksgiving. Children in other classes may be inspired to put on their own play by using the information in this book or will surely just enjoy reading it. Fiction, Highly Recommended. 1999, HarperCollins, Unpaged, $14.89. Grades Preschool-K. Reviewer: Patty Derrickson (Heart of Texas Reviews)
Best Books:
   Children's Catalog, Eighteenth Edition, 2001 ; H.W. Wilson; United States
ISBN: 0-06-027795-5
ISBN: 0-06-028388-2

Thanksgiving Day
Mari C. Schuh
   The books in the "National Holidays" series follow the same general format. There is an opening note to parents and teachers that states, "This series supports national social studies standards related to understanding events that celebrate the values and principles of American democracy." Even though this book is meant for very young readers, it is set up along the lines of books that older students would use for research and reference. It has a table of contents, a glossary entitled "Words to Know", references that include both books and Internet sites, and an index that also serves as a word list. The text consists of simple declarative sentences accompanied by full-page illustration, which are in most cases photographs. It tells readers that Thanksgiving Day is one when we all pause to be grateful for what we have, and it is celebrated on the fourth Thursday in November. This holiday was first celebrated by the early settlers in what is now the United States. What is missing from this book is the history behind the holiday and when it became an official US holiday. The balance of the text discusses ways that the holiday is celebrated noting that for most, it is a day to enjoy a great meal (turkey and all the trimmings) with family and friends, and to relax and have fun. 2003, Pebble Books/CapstonePress, $14.60. Ages 5 to 7. Reviewer: Marilyn Courtot (Children's Literature)
ISBN: 0-7368-1654-2

Thanksgiving Day at Our House: Thanksgiving Poems for the Very Young
Nancy White Carlstrom
Illustrated by R. W. Alley
   The anticipation, preparation and celebration of family at this autumn feast are all represented in these fifteen short and peppy poems. Carlstrom begins with "The Day Before," when children reenact the first Thanksgiving at school and concludes with a "Goodnight Prayer" on Thanksgiving night when a child thanks God for all the blessings of a good day. Intermingled are poems such as "Granny's Thanksgiving" in which she tells the children what Thanksgiving Day was like when she was a girl. The children have their own "Thanksgiving Parade," play "Thanksgiving Charades" and become solemn as they recite the "Prayer for Others." Alley's illustrations show a busy family and happy relatives (including the dogs). There is a nice integration of illustrations and poems. For example, the second and third poems are on a two-page spread that shows the children performing a play on stage at school. With the poem, "Thank You Singing Game" Alley has drawn the family posing for a photograph while another relative walks around with his video camera. These kid-centered poems, now available in a paperback edition, present a wide range of feelings about this American holiday and will be fun to share with family members. 2002 (orig. 1999), Aladdin Paperbacks/ Simon & Schuster, Ages 4 to 8, $6.99. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 0-689-85318-1
ISBN: 0-689-80360-5

Thanksgiving Is Here!
Diane Goode
   At Grandma and Grandpa's house the turkey goes in the oven when the sun comes up. Ding dong! The doorbell begins to ring. Everyone has come to help--Mom and Pop, Maggie and baby Jack and uncles and aunts and lots of cousins. Peel potatoes, roll out dough, move the piano and the sofa because "we need lots of room at Thanksgiving." All the tables are pushed together to make one big table with mismatched chairs all around--"but we don't mind. We all have a place at the table." Cranberries pop and cornbread sizzles while everyone yakkety-yaks until it is time for dinner. After giving thanks and unfolding napkins "we eat till we're full at Thanksgiving." Everyone clears and washes and dries dishes. And after naps and walks and much more yakkety-yakking, everyone hurries back to the table for pie. "...we're never too full for dessert." When the sun goes down, everyone kisses goodbye and tells Grandma and Grandpa not to worry. "We'll be back." Delightfully detailed watercolor-and-ink illustrations invite readers to take another look at this noisy, active family. This is a celebration of family and, as the author states, "a family is something worth celebrating." 2003, Harper Collins Publishers, Ages 4 to 7, $15.99. Reviewer: Anita Barnes Lowen
ISBN: 0-06-051588-0
ISBN: 0-06-051589-9

Thanksgiving: What Makes It Special?
Harold Myra
Illustrated by Jane Kurisu
   Written by Harold Myra, President and CEO of Christianity Today, Inc., this book seeks to imbue the Thanksgiving holiday with more Christian values. The story is a conversation between a family of Mom and Dad and kids as they prepare a Thanksgiving meal together. The parents intervene to discuss the true meaning of the Thanksgiving after the radio announcer blurts out, "Happy Turkey Day!" The parents, and the very well behaved daughter, work to explain the significance of the pilgrims and Native American dinner and the roles of Jesus and Moses in the celebration of Thanksgiving. The whole family thanks Jesus as the car full of foster kids arrives at the house for dinner. At a time when greater tolerance is indeed needed in the world, it is nice to think that a day already set aside could represent this, but it's questionable whether the relationship between the pilgrims and Native Americans is really the example of tolerance to which we should look. The text and the pictures do not match which may prove a bit confusing for the beginning reader. It is always a good reminder to give thanks for those things for which we are truly grateful, but this is very specifically for Christian families. 2002, Tommy Nelson, Ages 7 to 12, $7.99. Reviewer: Sarah Seage
ISBN: 1-4003-0006-1

Thanksgiving on Thursday
Mary Pope Osborne
Illustrated by Sal Murdocca
   Thanksgiving is number 27 in the "Magic tree House" series for kids. This time it is actually Thanksgiving Day and Jack and Annie end up back in 1621 to join the Pilgrims for the very first Thanksgiving. They are warmly welcomed by Governor Bradford, looked at with suspicion by Captain Miles Standish and befriended by Squanto. Author Osborne does manage to introduce some facts about cooking and gathering food and the great difficulties the Pilgrims faced during their first winter (half of the group perished), and she does give Priscilla, who eventually maries John Alden, a bit of a personality. The story really stretches as far as credibility is concerned, however, kids will probably suspend belief and enjoy a pleasant read, absorb a few facts and be thankful that they live in modern times and can enjoy a Thanksgiving dinner with their own family and friends. 2002, Random House, Ages 5 to 7, $3.99. Reviewer: Marilyn Courtot
ISBN: 0-375-80615-6

This First Thanksgiving Day: A Counting Story
Laura Krauss Melmed
Illustrated by Mark Buehner
   What are the ingredients for a great Thanksgiving? Food, family, friends, and favorite stories. Acclaimed author Laura Krauss Melmed leads a romp to the table in This First Thanksgiving Day. In this counting story, pilgrim and Native American children are shown gathering nuts, harvesting turnips, fetching water--and all bringing something to the "12 tables groaning" under the feast that serves as a satisfying finale. Mark Buehner's colorful illustrations are both engaging and informative, showing how people lived in our country almost 400 years ago. 2001, HarperCollins, $15.95. Ages 2 to 5. Reviewer: Mary Quattlebaum (Children's Literature)

This First Thanksgiving Day: A Counting Story
Laura Krauss Melmed
Illustrated by Mark Buehner
   Simple rhymes for each number from one to twelve fill in some background about the Pilgrim and Wampanoag children preparing for the Thanksgiving feast. All join together at twelve tables in a prayer of thanks. Everyone is happy and everything seems fine in this probably more legendary than truthful taste of the holiday's history. Buehner's paintings supply youngsters going about their chores in a benign autumn setting of fall leaves and intense blue sky. The color-rich double pages depict the preparations, historic costumes and artifacts with an emphasis on the decorative rather than the details. 2001, HarperCollins Publishers, $15.95. Ages 3 to 6. Reviewers: Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz (Children's Literature)

This First Thanksgiving Day: A Counting Story
Laura Krauss Melmed
Illustrated by Mark Buehner
   This is probably the best Thanksgiving book that I have read in recent years. The illustrations are eye-catching and wonderfully drawn. The book also contains rhyming words on every page along with numbers that help a young reader learn to count. The artwork with the Pilgrims and Native Americans, the trees, animals, ocean, and the entire scenery in the book is exceptional. This is a great book to help explain the settlement of the Pilgrims, the first Thanksgiving, and how to count to a young learner. This is a highly recommended book for children and adults. Nonfiction (811), Highly Recommended. 2001, HarperCollins, Unpaged, $15.89. Grades PreK-2. Reviewer: Carl Contreras (Heart of Texas Reviews (Vol. 14, No. 2)) ISBN: 0-688-14554-X

Tricky Turkey Tongue Twisters
Quinlan B. Lee
Illustrated by Clive Scruton
   Alliterative text and fold out pages are the cornerstone of this Thanksgiving oriented paperback book. Cars cart cavorting kids to family feasting. Groups gather and kids hid from horrible hugs. Beans boil and brown bread burns as corn is creamed. The feast is finally forthcoming and baby Greg gobbles the yummy yams. After dinner bring sleepers snoring. Each fold out page reveals a humorous illustration of the kids involved in some wacky activity. One little girl with food all over her face is running to hide from overbearing relatives. Space ships and robots are flying around the kitchen while Mom is making mashed potatoes. Sarah gets squirted in the face by a squished squash. The young readers will particularly enjoy the chaos revealed in the fold out pages. It's nice to see the family consist of various ethnic groups and body types. All of the members of the family are seen making a contribution to the festivities. The stylized illustrations from a variety of perspectives add to the entertainment. 2002, HarperCollins, Ages 3 to 6, $6.99. Reviewer: Kristin Harris
ISBN: 0-694-01682-9

Turk and Runt
Lisa Wheeler
Illustrated by Frank Ansley
   This is the perfect Thanksgiving giggle! Runt's older brother Turk, is a fine specimen of a turkey. Big, meaty, juicy... you know, dinner. Runt (his name is a perfect description) understands what turkeys mean to people, however Turk and his parents do not. Turk's parents are quite proud of their big boy, "He's a dancer," said his mother. "He's an athlete," said his father. "He's a goner," said his brother, Runt. But no one ever listened to Runt." Runt's brains save the day more than once and the final page of this book will have you smiling every time you think about it. 2002, Atheneum, Ages 4 to 7, $15.95. Reviewer: Sharon Levin
ISBN: 0-689-84761-0

Turkey Monster Thanksgiving
Anne Warren Smith
   Every year Katie, her dad, and little brother Tyler experience a simple Thanksgiving--no frills, no thrills. They eat pizza and revel in the low-key, lazy day. But once Katie discovers that her friend Claire has invited forty people to a perfect Thanksgiving dinner, Katie begins to doubt her family's way of celebrating. Author Anne Warren Smith tackles some tough subjects in this unassuming and intriguing book. Themes include the challenge of single fathers raising young kids, abandonment by a mother, society's view of the situations, and learning what is important or not when it comes to defining family. The playful dialogue between Katie and Claire in the first few pages sets the pace for things to come. Immediately the reader knows Katie lacks concern with how others view her situation, and that Claire's perfection dictates everything she does. It is quickly understood that this will be a bone of contention. The plot moves along steadily and engages young readers. Katie's actions demonstrate her need to wrestle with "keeping up with the Joneses," when she convinces Dad that they, too, need a regular Thanksgiving with company. The characters show authenticity and individuality and readers may readily identify with Katie or Claire. Amusing episodes will keep readers yearning for more. Some humorous happenings surface front and center when Katie attempts to be perfect in the kitchen using recipes for the "time-stressed" woman. In the end, when it appears that everything has gone wrong, Katie discovers the importance of family. It may be surmised that the reader will, too. 2003, Albert Whitman & Company, Ages 7 to 10, $13.95. Reviewer: Nancy Garhan Attebury
ISBN: 0-8075-8125-9

Turkeys Never Gobble
Joan Holub
Illustrated by Jennifer Beck Harris
   Mr. Fox is hosting the Thanksgiving celebration at his home this year. Families of bears, chickens, hedgehogs, boars and tigers are among the folks coming for the feast. The alligators are good cooks and bring food. The hippos are helpful in the kitchen. Even the monkeys are on their best behavior and wash their hands before they mix, measure and chop. Napkins are folded at the table and the Foxes bring out the food. The good manners continue when the rhinos don't run or act rude. We've been reminded not to poke fun of the food we don't like, not to yak the loudest and not to gobble our food. Just as it appears that this story is all about being on our best behavior, things get interesting. Moose spills some soup and Monkey yells "Food Fight". The animals get messy at their Thanksgiving feast and turn into wild beasts. Bright, kid friendly illustrations in a color palette appropriate for all enhance this board book that will be most appreciated for its twist at the end. 2002, Harper Collins, Ages 2 to 6, $5.99. Reviewer: Kristin Harris
ISBN: 0-06-008091-4

'Twas the Day After Thanksgiving
Mavis Smith
   It's the day after Thanksgiving and the family is cleaning up from the feast and eating leftovers. They may not be aware of the mouse family that lives in their house; but they are enjoying the left over too. Each spread contains a flap to lift to reveal either a member of the mouse family or some other aspect of the story. Breakfast was turkey and toast; lunch was a turkey burger and chips. Even for dinner, when they were craving something different, Mom makes turkey stew. The dessert is made of turkey. Under the flaps are the activities of the mouse family, a look at Mom's turkey stew, or a mouse taking some of the dessert with the turkey wishbone. Even the mouse family wishes for something to eat besides turkey. Their dreams are answered when the doorbell rings with a pizza delivery boy and a free pizza. Guess what's all over the pizza. Only the faces of the mouse family are visible in plain illustrations. 2002, Simon and Schuster, Ages 3 to 6, $5.99. Reviewer: Kristin Harris
ISBN: 0-689-85234-7

The Very First Thanksgiving Day
Rhonda Gowler Greene
Paintings by Susan Gaber
   This is the story of the first Thanksgiving. The author tells this story in cumulative rhyme. The book is written is a circular format, beginning and ending with the feast. During the telling of the story, the importance of the help offered by the Indians is detailed. The Pilgrims learned from the natives how to farm in this new land. The growth and organization of the settlement is explained as well as the harshness of the winter snows. The Pilgrims' voyage across the ocean in the Mayflower is included. The beautiful paintings by Susan Gaber transport the reader back to these struggling times. Much research was done to include meticulous details about the scenery and the people. Through the written text and the illustrations, the reader is helped to understand the feelings of these early settlers3/4their fears, anxieties, and hopes. This book will be a yearly favorite for children of all ages. 2002, Atheneum Books for Young Readers, Ages 3 to 6, $15.95. Reviewer: Maureen Boyle
ISBN: 0-689-83301-6

Wild Turkeys
John E. Becker
   It is a tradition for the president of the United States to "officially pardon" a wild turkey near Thanksgiving Day in order to return it to its home in the wild. This tradition may have been the brainchild of President Theodore Roosevelt who passed the Federal Aid in Wildlife Restoration Act in 1937 in an attempt to save the wild bird from extinction. The wild turkey has existed for more than eleven million years and has been domesticated for nearly five hundred years. Although it is a bird with many natural defenses (keen eyesight, acute hearing, camouflage, and flight speed), it has been an easy prey for humans for centuries. For this reason alone, the wild turkey has been in a long fight for survival. This book goes into detail about this very issue. Readers will learn the failures and successes of official programs designed to protect the bird. The information can get heavy at times and will most likely overwhelm the reader looking for "fun facts" about the bird. Photographs throughout the text are entertaining, bringing some whimsicality to the read. It is part of the "Returning to Wildlife" series. 2003, KidHaven Press, Ages 8 to 12, $23.70. Reviewer: Andrea Sears Andrews
ISBN: 0-7377-1288-0

Word Bird's Thanksgiving Words
Jane Belk Moncure
Illustrated by Chris McEwan
   With one word or term per page, readers are introduced to the vocabulary associated with this autumn holiday. There are no definitions given; only the words. Readers will find such terms as Mayflower, Pilgrims, Native Americans, Teepee, Native American Crafts, and more. To sum things up, or provide some repetition for the beginning reader, all the words are presented in a double-page spread at the back of the book. Word Bird and his animal friends are dressed as Pilgrims and Native Americans who are in generic garments. They are not in the clothing of the Wampanoag people. Baskets with "Native American foods" are shown but it is difficult to determine what is in the baskets. These cutesy illustrations limit the audience to the very young. Readers will gain little from this book other than word recognition. They will be confused by the generalized Native American "look" that is presented in the illustrations. Unless there is a need to acquaint the reader with a book, these words can be learned from cards. 2002, The Child's World, Ages 4 to 6, $21.36. Reviewer: Sharon Salluzzo
ISBN: 1-56766-628-0

To return to our most recent Thanksgiving feature, click here.

To stay up to date on new books on this topic, consider subscribing to The Children's Literature Comprehensive Database. For your free trial, click here.

If you’re interested in reviewing children's and young adult books, then send a resume and writing sample to marilyn@childrenslit.com.

Back to Top